Andy Seybold’s Public Safety Advocate, May 26, 2016

Opting Out of FirstNet Each state has the right to opt out of the plan FirstNet and the selected partner vendor presents to it. However, it the state does opt out, it is then required to jump through a number of hoops in order to be able to build out its portion of the network. First it must submit a plan to the FCC for approval, then both the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) and FirstNet become involved in the process. The state has to negotiate a lease for the spectrum with FirstNet and then the NTIA has to approve a grant to help fund the state’s build. Opting out is a complex process with a lot of room for delays and problems. There is nothing I can find in the law that says a state can simply sit back and do nothing. In fact, it appears as though FirstNet will have the right to build in a state that either does not meet the opt-out criteria or merely decides not to be part of the network. All of this seems like a convoluted way to basically punish a state for not being part of FirstNet.

Let’s be clear here, this is not FirstNet’s set of rules, it is not even NTIA’s set of rules. Rather, this is how Congress crafted Title VI of the Middle Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act of 2012 that was signed into law. It is odd to me that members of Congress who are elected by the people in their states included this type of wording. Perhaps they understood that the network would better serve the Public Safety community if it were all one network, operated by a single entity, with the funds flowing to the RFP partner and to FirstNet to provide both profit for the RFP partner and funding to expand the network or add more coverage over time. The principal issues I see that could derail the opt-out process start with the FCC having to approve each and every state’s plan and to ensure the Radio Access Network or RAN (the cell sites, basically) is fully compatible with the FirstNet network for true interoperability. It is not clear how long the FCC will take to review each of the state’s requests.

To begin with, the FCC is long on attorneys and short on technical expertise. If it elects to fully use its powers under the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), it could choose to have a separate Public Notice and comment period for each state’s plan that is presented, the process could take months to complete. And FCC approval is only the first of three steps a state must go through. What if the FCC and FirstNet’s opinions differ on a state’s RAN architecture and the FCC approves it but FirstNet has an issue with it? Or the other way around? There is nothing in the legislation to address a possible stalemate, which could add more time. FirstNet holds the license for the spectrum, which is issued by the FCC, and the NTIA has no jurisdiction over the FirstNet spectrum. The NTIA only has control over federal government spectrum, not FirstNet spectrum even though FirstNet is technically an “independent authority” under the auspices of the NTIA and the Department of Commerce. So the first set of delays for a state to move forward in opt-out mode could be with the FCC’s approval. Next are the negotiations with FirstNet for a spectrum lease.

When FirstNet took over the BTOP grants that were issued by the NTIA to early builders, the spectrum lease issues took a lot of time to resolve. Some early builders could not come to terms with FirstNet and lost their grants. The state of Mississippi is one example of a failed agreement between a state and FirstNet. I am not sure this will be a major issue any longer since FirstNet has now successfully completed lease agreements with other early builders including Harris County, TX, LA-RICS, the State of New Jersey, and a few others. But any sticking point would require more time to complete the lease process. If a state is really smart it will ask for, and hopefully receive, the right to add more RAN to the state network using state and local funding as long as the RAN continues to meet both FCC and FirstNet interoperability criteria. That leaves the lease with the NTIA for funding. It appears that the money NTIA will have available to award to the state will be the money the winning RFP partner has indicated it would cost it to build out that state. And, of course, the funds for the grant will be taken from the $6.5 billion FirstNet will pay to the RFP partner as various build-out milestones are met. I am sure that none of the bidders would low-ball their cost estimates to build out the states they believe will opt-out, but if I were bidding I would be tempted to take that course of action, especially since the RFP enables the winning partner to go back into the opt-out states and try to cut a deal so it can then build out that state’s RAN as well as the rest of the network.

Moreover, if a number of states do opt out it is not really fair for the RFP partner planning to build out the network. If there are many delays in positioning opt-out states to move forward with their own build-out, the RFP partner will not be able to use the secondary spectrum in those states until the process is completed. This is not fair to the state, it is not fair to the Public Safety community, and it is not fair to the RFP partner that will be spending $billions on the network and will need to start deriving income from the network, and thus the secondary spectrum, as quickly as possible. There has to be a way to make this process easier. What if, for example, an opt-out state worked with FirstNet and FirstNet certified that its RAN architecture would work in the FirstNet network prior to the state going to the FCC. It seems to me that this one extra step could save time and money for all concerned since the FCC would be receiving a state plan that had already been approved as meeting the interoperability requirements of FirstNet. There is also probably a way to speed up both the spectrum lease and NTIA funding grants for these states and it appears to me, as a non-attorney, that the wording of the law would not preclude some ways of making the opt-out process easier for all parties as well as faster, which would benefit the state, Public Safety, FirstNet, and the RFP selected partner.

Finally this week I would like to call your attention to a report issued by the Wireless Innovation forum. This report addresses the issues related to the Evolving Complexity of Public Safety First Response. The lead-in to the report states, “‘Elements of Context for Cognitive Radio Based Public Safety Communications Systems’ shows how context can be used to manage Public Safety communications and recommends use cases.” Elements of the report include: • Overviews of the landscape and the role of FirstNet • Description of context aware cognitive radio • Context Aware Cognitive Radio for Public Safety: Model and Resources • Context Inputs for Cognitive Systems • Applications of Context for Public Safety • Recommendations The flyer for the report, which includes a link directly to the complete report is here . It is well done and worth reading. Be sure to look at the list of sponsors that support the Wireless Innovation Forum since they include, as you would expect, Motorola Solutions but also Thales, Finmeccanica, and the one that caught my eye, Google. Andrew M. Seybold
FCC cites public-safety needs, proposes to revamp network-outage reporting process to include IP …Urgent Communications via Google Alerts May 26 17:00 FCC commissioners vote to refine network-outage reports that must be filed to reflect the performance of legacy networks, in addition to exploring the …

Seffner man fined $48000 by FCC for using cell phone jammer on daily commuteTampabay.com via Google Alerts May 26 09:20 … which can disrupt all wireless and public safety communications in the area,” said FCC enforcement bureau chief Travis LeBlanc in a statement.

FirstNet Weekly Update to the Public Safety Advisory CommitteeNational Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts May 26 08:45 FirstNet Weekly Update to the Public Safety Advisory Committee (PSAC) …

FCC formalizes massive fines for selling, using cell-phone jammersNetwork World via Google Alerts May 25 17:20 This case highlights the danger posed to public safety by use of a single signal jamming device, which can disrupt all wireless and public safety …

Anticipation increases as FirstNet-proposal countdown hits the one-week markUrgent Communications via Google Alerts May 24 12:30 … as offerorsseeking the right build and maintain a nationwide public-safety broadband network (NPSBN) outlined in FirstNet’s request for proposals …

Verizon, AT&T Seen Submitting FirstNet BidsNational Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts May 20 06:01 Verizon Communications, Inc., and AT&T, Inc., are both likely to submit bids to the First Responder Network Authority (FirstNet), Wells Fargo Securities …

FirstNet Makes Progress, But Cost and Quality Concerns RemainFloridaNet via Google Alerts May 20 00:45 The First Responder Network Authority (FirstNet) is moving fast toward its goal of a dedicated nationwide public safety communications network. …

FCC Requires 800 MHz Rebanding ReportsNational Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts May 20 00:01 The Policy and Licensing Division of the FCC’s Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau today directed Maricopa County, Ariz., to file weekly …

Cybersecurity experts outline challenges associated with FirstNet, other public-safety …cyber security caucus via Google Alerts May 19 15:50 FirstNet plans to provide state-of-the-art cybersecurity by employing …

NETGEM : Elisa tests 4G in 700 MHz band4 Traders via Google Alerts May 26 18:01 Elisa’s 4G network already covers over 98 percent of the population, and the additional frequencies would be used to add capacity over a wider area, …

National Telecommunications & Information Administration Issues Voluntary Best Practices For …JD Supra via Google Alerts May 26 17:10 The Presidential Memorandum instructed NTIA to undertake this …

Alert: Data Breaches Are Changing Online Behaviors, Impacting BusinessMarketwired via Google Alerts May 26 17:10 In fact, the results of a survey recently released by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) indicate that consumers …

The National Telecommunications and Information Administration has released new …Business Jets – in the news via Google Alerts May 26 15:30 The National Telecommunications and Information Administration has released new recommended privacy guidelines for the use of unmanned …

EU Council backs 700 MHz for mobile broadbandNewsclip via Google Alerts May 26 14:10 “EU Council backs 700 MHz for mobile broadband…

FCC – Improving Public Safety Communications in the 800 MHz BandColorado Media.Net via Google Alerts May 26 14:01 From the FCC: Improving Public Safety Communications in the 800 MHz Band Granted in part and denied in part a request by Sprint for Bureau …

FCC sets out rules for $2bn rural broadband fundTotal Telecom May 26 12:02 U.S. telco watchdog seeks to facilitate network deployment in hard-to-reach areas.

With the opening of the 700 MHz band for mobile broadband an important step towards the …Quotes.net via Google Alerts May 26 09:10 Explore all famous quotations and sayings by Henk Kamp on Quotes.net.

NEC and Tait Communications team up on mission critical wirelessCSO Australia via Google Alerts May 26 01:00 NEC developed iPASOLINK VR with a view to supporting mobile operators’ and public safety mobile broadband networks’ growing needs to expand …

P25 & RPC Support Specialist (Nonprofit) Washington, DC 20003 Recruited byPostings via Google Alerts May 25 02:25 The Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) International is seeking an individual for the full-time position of P25 & RPC …

Rubio, Senators Urge Administration To Prevent Bad Internet Governance DealPress Releases – Newsroom – US Senator for Florida, Marco Rubio via Google Alerts May 25 00:15 The group of senators weighed in as the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) reviews the proposal from the Internet …

Reauthorization Of The National Telecommunications And Information Administrationzoofuyczak.ru via Google Alerts May 24 15:25 Reauthorization Of The National Telecommunications And Information Administration: Hearing Before The Subcommittee On Telecommunications, …

ICANN Won’t Even Be Accountable in Becoming AccountableLexology via Google Alerts May 24 11:30 As many of you know, the National Telecommunications & Information Administration (NTIA), with no instructions on the matter from Congress to do so, …

Huawei and Vodafone opening ‘world’s first’ narrowband IoT Open LabFOT–Fiber Optical testers,tools and accessories via Google Alerts May 24 08:01 Fibra Opticas Tek is an experienced and faithful distributor providing China’s first class optical fiber testers,hand tools and accessories.

Bill would allow first responders to treat petsWopular via Google Alerts May 20 11:15 This bill would provide states and local communities with tools to prevent and treat drug …

FCC sees broadband improving patient access to behavioral careHealth Data Management via Google Alerts May 20 07:25 What’s required to drive the widespread adoption of telemedicine technologies to transform mental healthcare is regulatory creativity and …

RAW DATA: TrueNet April 2016 Broadband Report – NZ Internet now Better than USANational Business Review May 20 07:01 This month we compare webpage download speeds with those reported by the FCC who use nearly identical methods to TrueNet.

APCO International Announces 2016 Award WinnersPublic Safety Communications – APCO International via Google Alerts May 20 04:00 Alexandria, VA The Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) International is pleased to announce the winners of the 2016 …

NTIA Multistakeholder Group Agrees to Best Practices Addressing Privacy Issues Regarding use of …National Press Photographers Association via Google Alerts May 19 23:15 NTIA Multistakeholder Group Agrees to Best Practices Addressing Privacy …

NTIA Seeks Comment on ITU’s Role in Setting Technical Standards for IoT and Other Internet …Wiley Rein LLP via Google Alerts May 19 21:50 On May 17, 2016, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) released a request for comment (Request) on what roleif …

Privacy and Civil Liberties Protections at Heart of NTIA Best Practices for DronesPressReleasePoint via Google Alerts May 19 15:25 Today the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) shared a consensus set of voluntary best practices for for commercial …

Vodafone Completes Trial of Narrowband Internet of Things (NB-IoT)M2M2IoTPaper.com via Google Alerts May 19 08:20 Vodafone has announced it has successfully completed a trial of pre-standard Narrowband Internet of Things (NB-IoT). NB-IoT is a 4G technology that …

NTIA | Role of Government in the Advancement of the Internet of ThingsStandards – University of Michigan via Google Alerts May 19 07:15 Last Wednesday, May 11th, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) extended the deadline for public comment on an …