Andy Seybold’s Public Safety Advocate, December 9, 2016

Where FirstNet Stands The smoke has cleared after the press reports of the Rivada Mercury court filing for being removed from the final phase of review of the FirstNet RFP by the Department of the Interior (DOI). In my own post about this I mentioned I thought the DOI could, if it wanted to, still award the contract. However, upon review of other articles written later than mine it appears as though the DOJ (as opposed to the DOI) agreed not to award the FirstNet RFP until at least March 1, 2017. My Public Safety Advocate Special Edition discussing the Rivada Mercury court filing elicited a larger than usual number of responses from my Public Safety Advocate subscribers (it’s free), those it was passed around to, and those who read it on Linkedin.com.

Comparing the number of responses to the total of my subscriber base and the LinkedIn readership, it was almost a 6% response and I did not receive one negative comment. Most were “You hit it right on the head,” and “You are right, I also believe Rivada Mercury loses even if it wins the court case.” This number is hardly representative of the U.S. Public Safety community but the emails came from Public Safety people in at least 24 states and one tribal community. The usual response to my weekly posts is probably less than 1% of the combined readership.

Now there is more information out there that has been reported and is worth noting. If the court rules in favor of Rivada Mercury, it means it could be included in the final portion of the RFP FAR process (you have to love all the acronyms). However, if it loses it means Rivada caused the Public Safety community and FirstNet yet another delay. I don’t know if in a pre-award case Rivada would be able to appeal the decision but if it does it would certainly lead to even more delays. According to some this could lead to dire consequences for FirstNet and the Public Safety community but I am confident that even with the delays FirstNet and the federal government will prevail.

What I am not so thrilled about are the delays on top of the already almost inexcusable delays, piled on top of the slow pace of the federal system. I promised my wife once the network is up and running and populated with as many Public Safety personnel as possible I would retire, stop writing, consulting, and providing my educational sessions. The way things are going I guess I could turn 100 and still be sending out these weekly blogs! There is a balance between wanting to assist Public Safety and making money for the company expending billions of dollars up front to build the network. There are, of course, many costs associated with being visible within the Public Safety community and preparing for the RFP response. Hundreds of hours are expended and thousands of dollars are spent but each and every potential bidder faces similar costs and takes the same risks.

I was part of a very large, expensive team put together by a bidder, that, it turns out, pulled the plug on the project. It ate the costs it incurred because it did not believe upon close inspection the opportunity would be favorable to the company, and that others would probably be better suited to providing the network. However, it knew its initial investment would be a risk. The decision to stop work on the RFP was based purely on a financial model for this particular company and the way it operates. For this company, at this time, it was the right call. Companies bidding on projects take a risk and expend time, effort, and money. It is the way things work. As mentioned last week, I have been on teams that filed complaints and lawsuits and teams that walked away after a bid knowing we had done the best we could. I have also been on winning teams and carried the purchase order back to the office. When we lost we did not complain, we learned from our mistakes and bad judgement. When we complained and lost in a court of law, we withdrew. The few times we won by complaining or suing we really lost in the end.

I have to believe those who decided to exclude both pdvWireless and Rivada Mercury were thorough and careful when they made their decisions. They had to anticipate there could be a legal challenge to their actions, therefore I am willing to bet that all their i’s are dotted and t’s crossed, checked, and double checked. It is up to the court to determine the outcome of all of this, and FirstNet and the potential winner and its partners will have to wait some more, as will the Public Safety community. But I can tell you that every time first responders are faced with a major incident and need coordination, video, data, and other broadband services they will remember why they do not yet have them. All of the bidders were interested in making money for sure, but some are as interested in serving the common good and helping the Public Safety community as they did before FirstNet was born as well as afterward. The issue to me is which of the RFP respondents are more interested in turning a profit as quickly as possible and which are willing to be in this for the long haul as an investment that will not only pay dividends to the company and its shareholders but to the Public Safety community as well. Andrew M. Seybold

AT&T is apparent selection to build FirstNet, as Rivada Mercury files protest over elimination from bidUrgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec  2 13:10 … FirstNet’s contractor to build and operate the much-anticipated nationwide public-safety broadband network (NPSBN)an action that points to AT&T …

AT&T to Nab Lucrative FirstNet Emergency Network Contractuhtml5game.com via Google Alerts Dec  8 05:00 The plans for the wireless emergency network were born shortly after 9/11, but the …

Band 14 Public-Safety LTE Demo Network Used for Ohio State Football GameRRMEdia Group via Google Alerts Dec  7 15:31 ESChat, Intrepid Networks, Redline Communications and Sonim Technologies demonstrated a dedicated public-safety Long Term Evolution (LTE) …

FirstNet Committee and Board Meeting, December 13-14, 2016FirstNet via Google Alerts Dec  7 14:11 The Act directs FirstNet to ensure the building, deployment, and operation of a nationwide, interoperable public safety broadband network.

Securing Public Safety Networks The Apco Perspective PDF f177fc16ac1fbeeeac6fbea373569fb0AnonDNS via Google Alerts Dec  7 05:35 Read online securing public safety networks the apco perspective jay …

Why public safety should be excited by FirstNet’s prospects, despite potential delaysUrgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec  6 18:20 Why public safety should be excited by FirstNet’s prospects, despite …

Comcast Exec Admits That Net Neutrality Is Not As Scary As Industry Made It Out To BeThe Consumerist via Google Alerts Dec  9 12:45 When the FCC finalized its new net neutrality rules in 2015, adding more regulatory control over broadband data services, the cable industry freaked …

Global Public Safety Networks Market, Forecast to 2020: $17.6 Billion Market for Networks …Satellite PR News via Google Alerts Dec  9 00:00 … forecasts through 2020 are provided by region and top countries, and a look at the transition to mobile broadband services spending is included.

Snapshot:S&T and APCO Partnerto Improve Interoperability and Security of Public Safety Mobile …Newswise via Google Alerts Dec  8 20:16 Newswise The Department of Homeland Security Science and Technology Directorate (S&T) and the Association of Public-Safety Communications …

The IoT: Gateway for enterprise hackersCSO Online via Google Alerts Dec  8 16:31 Baxley mentioned Sigfox, LoRa and NarrowBand IOT, but added that, huge players like Comcast, Verizon and Orange have publicly announced they …

Mediacom Says Entire Network Will Be Gigabit-Ready by Year”s EndDSL Reports via Google Alerts Dec  8 11:55 That said, the ISP also took a shot at the FCC’s net neutrality rules, which ISPs claimed would destroy network investment in the broadband sector (tip: …

Senate Commerce, Science & Transportation Committee Issues Report on Securing Access to …Targeted News Service via Google Alerts Dec  8 10:45 The bill also would direct the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to study the public safety benefits and technical feasibility of alternative …

Net Neutrality, Other FCC Reforms Could Be Scrapped Under TrumpTwice via Google Alerts Dec  7 12:55 A host of consumer-friendly FCC reforms instituted under chairman Tom Wheeler (net neutrality, cable-box competition, broadband privacy protections …

AACG’s Analysis Shows Continued Growth in Broadband Competition, as Debate over Future of Net Neutrality Heats UpBusiness Wire Dec  7 08:24 BOSTON–(BUSINESS WIRE)–The latest broadband performance results by Advanced Analytical Consulting Group (AACG) show that service levels continued to increase through 2015. The results are based on the most recent data from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) released in September 2016 for service through December 2015. This is the second in a series of reports by AACG, providing a consistent set of measures of broadband service over time. AACG’s previous report showed that the analyse

First Responders Leverage Private LTE Network During Major Central Ohio Sporting EventIT Business Net via Google Alerts Dec  7 06:30 The turnkey private Band 14 LTE network was planned, designed, provided, installed and operated by Redline. It included ENodeB’s (eNB), the …

Rivada Mercury Networks Takes FirstNet to CourtAGL via Google Alerts Dec  7 00:10 Rivada Mercury Networks Takes FirstNet to Court …

Internet Policy Task Force Public Meeting to Include Blockchain DiscussionDCEBrief via Google Alerts Dec  6 19:40 … and John Morris, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA)’s Associate Administrator and Director of Internet Policy.

FirstNet deal ‘going to AT&T’ reportGlobal Telecoms Business via Google Alerts Dec  6 19:35 The First Responder Network Authority (FirstNet) the US government body charged …

Echostar : FCC Broadband Report Ranks HughesNet #1 in Meeting Advertised Performance4 Traders via Google Alerts Dec  6 19:25 Germantown, Md. — The Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) sixth annual report on consumer broadband services has ranked HughesNet …