Andy Seybold’s Public Safety Advocate, February 23, 2017

Five-Plus Years of FirstNet!  FirstNet celebrates its five-year anniversary this month. The law that created FirstNet was signed by the President of the United States on February 22, 2017. However, the work really began when President Bush signed a law in 2006 requiring TV stations to vacate channels 52-69 no later than February 2008. Also in 2006, there was a series of discussions regarding the creation of a Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network (NPSBN) and in 2007, the FCC carved out 10 MHz (5X5) of the 700-MHz spectrum being vacated by TV stations, and then designated another 10 MHz of spectrum, known as the D-block to be bid on during auctions. The winner would work with Public Safety to create a private/public partnership to build out a nationwide broadband network.

Those driving this series of events included Morgan O’Brien, co-founder of Nextel, and Chief Harlin McEwen (Ret), who quickly became the champion of the Public Safety broadband network. In 2007, the Public Safety Spectrum Trust (PSST), a non-profit corporation, was chosen by the FCC to hold the Public Safety broadband license. Chief McEwen was Chairman of the PSST and the board of directors was made up of representatives from fifteen national Public Safety organizations. When the D-block failed to be won at auction, the Public Safety community and the PSST worked with Congress to add the D-block to the 10 MHz of existing Public Safety spectrum to create a 10X10-MHz nationwide system.

This idea was opposed by several commercial network operators that had missed out on the 700-MHz spectrum and wanted the D-block to be re-auctioned without Public Safety restrictions. They were very vocal in their opposition, created several websites, and filed reams of documents with the FCC trying to prove Public Safety did not need more than 10 MHz of spectrum to meet its broadband needs. This opposition led to the creation of the Public Safety Alliance (PSA), which represented every form of the Public Safety community and included organizations such as the national association of governors and of mayors and had the support of many vendors within the wireless community as well as the two largest network operators.

It took the PSST, the PSA, APCO, NPSTC, and many other organizations until 2011 to gain traction with members of Congress and to convince some within the FCC that Public Safety would need access to more than the 10 MHz of spectrum already allocated. Tests were run simulating real-world capacity requirements using a variety of scenarios on a three-cell Public Safety LTE network that had been deployed by Motorola in Alameda County, CA. Those opposing the addition of the D-block were using the standard method of calculating commercial network capacity, using nineteen sites, each with three sectors. They assumed interference was common across all cell sectors, and then calculated the amount of traffic that could be handled over the network.

The issue came down to the fact that most local incidents occur within a rather small geographic area but require a large number of Public Safety personnel usually including law, fire, and EMS. This means capacity of the network needs to be calculated on a cell-sector basis as opposed to a set of wide-area network calculations. Remember too that LTE broadband provides faster data rates from the cell site down to field devices than in the upward direction. During an incident, the need for data and video services will be in both directions, to and from the incident, therefore capacity and speed of both the up and down portions of the network need to be put into perspective. These tests and the subsequent report provided to the FCC and members of Congress showed the Public Safety community needed access to a full 20 MHz (10X10 MHz) of spectrum, not only the 10 MHz already assigned.

While the discussions and testing were looking at network capacity, other roadblocks were put in the way of the decision on the D-block but the PSA found ways around each of these. One of the smartest things PSA did was to admit to those in the federal government that the Public Safety community would need an organization to oversee the build-out the network. Thus, within the Middle-Class Tax Relief Bill of 2012, Title VI, FirstNet was created as an independent authority under the NTIA, which is part of the Department of Commerce, and established a board of directors made up of department heads from the federal government, members of the business community, and members of the Public Safety community.

Since its inception in 2012, FirstNet has been working toward an award of the contract for a partner to build, operate, and maintain the network. In the early years, FirstNet was hampered by two things. The first was an attitude within the NTIA that FirstNet could not be an “independent authority” and therefore, frankly, some within the NTIA were heavy-handed in their dealings with FirstNet. Second was a serious distraction when allegations were made about improper hiring of consultants, and even charges of conflicts of interest. This resulted in all contractors, including those hired independently of the first group, being terminated. It also resulted in a delay of more than nine months in FirstNet returning to a functioning organization.

Then FirstNet found its sea legs, people were hired, changes were made, progress was plotted, deadlines were promised and kept, and it started to look as though FirstNet was back on track and moving ahead, still at a snail’s pace it seems to those of us on the outside, but to those accustomed to working with the federal government, it probably seemed like light speed. Public Safety could finally become excited about FirstNet and the promise of its own broadband network. All that was left to do was to award the RFP contract for a partner and start putting up antennas! However, once again, there have been delays, this time due to a court challenge of the RFP process. The court will hopefully resolve this issue soon and then FirstNet can award the contract.

Those who have worked at FirstNet know the obstacles of being part of the federal government, the delays, endless red tape, and rules and regulations that must be followed. They have persevered nonetheless and it appears that morale has been high, though the further delay caused by the lawsuit had to have been met with groans and disappointment from the folks who for the past few years have spent more time inside airplanes than their own homes. Let’s hope this latest delay is the last one before we start seeing progress and the states can see concrete presentations on what FirstNet coverage will be at first. Hopefully, each state will be able to work with FirstNet and the RFP partner to find ways to improve both coverage and network capacity where needed over time.

The reality of these increases in coverage is that they really should be the purview of the local jurisdictions. The first responders are the only ones who know their areas and coverage their LMR systems provide as well as coverage the commercial networks provide. It is one thing for the state to work with FirstNet to determine the coverage needed within the state if the state has, indeed, worked with those in the local jurisdictions. However, it is another if the state has simply stipulated a percentage of coverage like the one contained in the California RFI, which is a coverage requirement not being met today by any combination of LMR systems or any commercial operators’ systems. It is unrealistic to assume FirstNet will be able to meet such a requirement.

Years ago when we were testing pagers for one of the nationwide paging companies, we enlisted paramedics in the areas we were testing for the simple reason that EMS teams were all over the area, in buildings, in parking garages, and in other spots where incidents occur. We found if we could provide coverage for EMS teams we had coverage that was good enough for everyone. It is good that FirstNet is working with the states, and hopefully the states are working with the locals, but I am hearing that is not happening in many states. I hope before FirstNet shows up in a county or city those in that jurisdiction who are familiar with the existing coverage and requirements will have an opportunity to give their input to the contractor and work with the contractor and FirstNet over time to make sure their coverage needs are taken into account.

FirstNet is five years old this month but those who have been working to have the spectrum assigned to Public Safety and pushing for a FirstNet-type organization are celebrating at least ten years of effort. Everyone is ready for FirstNet’s next few years to be the most productive, putting the network in place, devices into first responders hands, and applications on the devices. I hope when FirstNet is ten, the Public Safety community has a robust, functional nationwide Public Safety broadband network for data and video services, and perhaps is also providing first responders with the capability of using FirstNet for interoperable push-to-talk in conjunction with LMR systems that are all still in operation and providing the same level of voice communications as today.

It seems like only yesterday the term ‘FirstNet’ was first used, but it has been five years! Congrats to all who are part of the FirstNet team. Keep up the great work! Andrew M. Seybold

FirstNet Annual Report: Fiscal Year 2016 Marked Significant Achievements in Making Network a …FirstNet via Google Alerts
Feb 22 20:25 FirstNet stands on the cusp of completing the acquisition process and moving forward with the deployment of public safety’s network. We look forward …

FirstNet: Building the Nation’s Dedicated, Advanced Public Safety Communications NetworkSatellite PR News via Google Alerts
Feb 23 13:26 Lives depend on first responders’ ability to communicate in disaster and emergency. That is why FirstNet was created to develop a wireless, mobile …

America’s 9-1-1 infrastructure is showing cracks, tooThe Hill via Google Alerts
Feb 23 11:40 … and the federal government’s FirstNet authority is developing a wireless broadband network for public safety field responders. But our 9-1-1 centers …

Boston, BayRICS to court: Please decide FirstNet case, so network construction can begin ASAPUrgent Communications via Google Alerts
Feb 23 03:35 Having a modern, reliable, and dedicated public-safety communications network is critically important to the safety of residents of municipalities …

LTE-U R gd 2 go: FCC gives unlicensed spectrum its coat, pushes it out the doorThe Register via Google Alerts
Feb 22 21:00 … LTE Unlicensed to ensure that unlicensed spectrum remains open for permission-less innovation to enable faster, better mobile broadband and that …

FirstNet finds experience to be the best teacherGCN.com via Google Alerts
Feb 22 17:52 FirstNet, the network authority that aims to provide a single interoperable platform for emergency and daily public safety communications, described …

Worldwide Public-Safety LTE Network DelaysMission Critical Communications via Google Alerts
Feb 21 22:05 Rolling out a nationwide public-safety broadband network is difficult and uncharted territory. The three countries that are likely the furthest along in …

Five years later, public safety can see a light at the end of FirstNet tunnelUrgent Communications via Google Alerts
Feb 21 19:35 However, a generally overlooked feature of the bill finally is on the verge of becoming reality: FirstNet’s nationwide public-safety broadband network.

FCC chief wants smartphones’ hidden FM radios turned on, but won’t do anything about itThe Verge via Google Alerts
Feb 16 12:52 In his speech this morning, he even says you could make a case for activating chips on public safety grounds alone, since radio could enable …

Under My Chairmanship, Radio Won’t Be NeglectedRadio World via Google Alerts
Feb 16 10:52 The FCC has an expert advisory panel on public safety issues that has also advocated enabling FM radio chips on smartphones. It pointed out that, …

Public-Safety Groups Support FCC Proceeding to Address 9-1-1 AppsMission Critical Communications via Google Alerts
Feb 16 10:30 In its comments, the Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) International said it is working to ensure apps are safe and …

TCCA defines key points for public safety LTE network rollout decisionsTetra Today via Google Alerts
Feb 16 04:10 Commercial mobile network operators already offer broadband service, and can deliver mobile broadband to public safety services. Many public …

FCC rolls back net neutrality ISP transparency rulesPC World
Feb 23 15:01 The U.S. Federal Communications Commission has voted to roll back some net neutrality regulations that require broadband providers to inform customers about their network management practices. The Republican-controlled FCC on Thursday suspended the net neutrality transparency requirements for broadband providers with fewer than 250,000 subscribers. Critics called the decision anticonsumer. The transparency rule, waived for five years in a 2-1 party-line vote Thursday, requires broadband provider

FCC Seeks Comment On Rule To Let TV Stations Test Next Gen TransmissionsDeadline via Google Alerts
Feb 23 14:52 My position is clear: Let’s allow broadcasters who wish to move forward with ATSC 3.0 pursue this pro-consumer, pro-public safety path as quickly as …

NTIA Extends Comment Period for Its Paper “Fostering the Advancement of the Internet of Things”CircleID via Google Alerts
Feb 23 14:20 Robert Cannon writes: Over the past year, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration in the Department of Commerce has …

Sequans and Orion Labs Partner to Develop First LTE-enabled Wearable with Monarch LTE-M ChipYahoo Finance via Google Alerts
Feb 23 14:11 Monarch is the world’s first and most highly-optimized LTE-M (Cat M1) and NB-IoT (Cat NB1) chip. It is purpose-built for narrowband IoT applications, …

Deutsche Telekom to expand NarrowBand-IoT across EuropeTelecom Lead via Google Alerts
Feb 23 14:11 DEUTSCHE TELEKOM revenue details Deutsche Telekom will launch NarrowBand-IoT (NB-IoT) in Germany in the second quarter of 2017 as part of …

FCC Greenlights ATSC 3.0TV Technology via Google Alerts
Feb 23 12:51 With support from television manufacturers, public TV stations and the public safety community, NAB looks forward to next-gen TV’s giant leap into …

NTIA Offers Expanded Federal Government Spectrum Use ReportsRadio magazine via Google Alerts
Feb 22 23:35 WASHINGTON The National Telecommunications & Information Administration has expanded its Federal Government Spectrum Compendium, the …

Broadband Fixed Wireless Networks (Standards & Protocols)Revista AMIGA via Google Alerts
Feb 22 22:10 Create a nationwide interoperable public safety wireless broadband communications network (public safety …

FCC invites comments on ARRL petition to allocate new 5 MHz bandSouthgate Amateur Radio Club via Google Alerts
Feb 22 07:35 NTIA – the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, which regulates federal spectrum – initially proposed the five channels for …

Nokia, Intel launch labs to bring 5G to the marketIT News Africa via Google Alerts
Feb 22 06:45 Nokia and Intel who have a long history of collaboration, including recent collaborations on Narrow Band IoT (NB-IoT), data center and network …

Frontier: CenturyLink-Level 3 Merger ‘Contrary to the Public Interest’ Without ConditionsBilling World and OSS Today
Feb 22 06:30 In an FCC filing, Frontier Communications said approving the CenturyLink-Level 3 merger without conditions could hurt rural broadband deployment and affordability.

AT&T Urges FCC To Nix ‘Cadillac’ Broadband Expansion GoalsLaw360 via Google Alerts
Feb 22 00:10 The hard fact of limited subsidy money shows the need to focus on coverage rather than speed, Joan Marsh, AT&T Inc.’s senior vice president of …

FCC Chairman wants all smartphones to have this vintage featureThe American Genius via Google Alerts
Feb 21 11:52 The FCC Chairman went on to argue in favor of putting the FM radio chips to good use: You could make a case for activating chips on public safety …

Broadband Tools Strengthen Rose Parade SecurityITbriefing.net via Google Alerts
Feb 16 12:56 Motorola Solutions built the network for LA-RICS, and it remains the largest U.S. broadband network dedicated for public safety. During the parade the …

Altair Introduces the Most Advanced and Integrated Narrowband CAT-M1 and NB1 Cellular IoT Chipsensorsmag.com via Google Alerts
Feb 16 10:56 HOD HASHARON, Israel — Altair Semiconductor introduces the ALT1250, a narrowband CAT-M1 and NB1 (NB-IoT) chipset that redefines the cellular …

OhioFirst.Net: Public Safety Broadband Pilot Network Pilot ProjectsThe Vimeo Player via Google Alerts
Feb 16 10:30 OhioFirst.Net: Public Safety Broadband Pilot Network Pilot Projects. from Kodjoarts, Columbus OH. 00:00. 04:21. Like. Add to Watch Later. Share.

Telefnica, Huawei, Kamstrup launch NB-IoT tech in LatamGlobal Telecoms Business via Google Alerts
Feb 16 07:55 Telefnica, Huawei and intelligent energy company Kamstrup have launched the first project with narrowband internet of things (IoT) technology in …

Altair unveils narrowband IoT chipsetTelecom Lead via Google Alerts
Feb 16 04:55 Altair Semiconductor chipset Altair Semiconductor, a provider of LTE chipsets, has unveiled the ALT1250, a narrowband CAT-M1 and NB1 (NB-IoT) …