Andy Seybold’s Public Safety Advocate, April 20, 2017

FirstNet Network Capacity Before FirstNet, those who wanted to auction the 5 MHz by 5 MHz portion of the 700-MHz spectrum known as the D block, which was adjacent to the 5 MHz by 5 MHz portion of the spectrum already licensed to the Public Safety Spectrum Trust (PSST) for Public Safety broadband contended that Public Safety would never need more than the 10 MHz of spectrum already allocated, therefore the D block should be auctioned with no restrictions to a network operator and used for commercial services. The Public Safety community prevailed and FirstNet was born having full priority access on 10 MHz X 10 MHz of spectrum now known as the FirstNet Spectrum or band 14.

FirstNet is licensed for the full 20 MHz of spectrum in the 700-MHz band that will provide full-priority access for Public Safety while permitting AT&T to make use of the excess spectrum for its own customers. This was designed in the law to be a full-up public/private partnership with the private partner footing most of the cost of the network build as well as operation of the network. The payback for the partner is the use of the spectrum when it is not needed by Public Safety. AT&T won the award and not only does Public Safety gain a band 14 network, it gains access to all of AT&T’s existing network spectrum on a priority or pre-emptive basis.

Considering that there was still concern about major incidents running out of spectrum, this new network design should mitigate most if not all of the congestion problems. To understand why this is true it is necessary to return to the results of the first real-world band 14 capacity testing that took place in 2011. The results of these tests were only one of the many reasons the Public Safety community won the battle. It was in 2011 that my team was hired by the East Bay Regional Communications Authority (EBRCSA) to run capacity tests on the first 5 MHz X 5 MHz band 14 system in operation. At that time only two cell sites were up and operational when we set about running some real-world tests. The project was called Project Cornerstone and the tests were run in Alameda County using sites built by Motorola, which had obtained a BTOP grant for the region from the NTIA prior to FirstNet.

The timing could not have been better since we were faced with several capacity studies provided to the FCC and Congress by two wireless network operators that were pushing for the D block to be auctioned. There was also a report from Dr. Peha, a visiting academic to the FCC from, I believe, Carnegie Melon University. It was his report that the FCC and members of Congress placed the most validity on simply, it appeared, because of his credentials. His main argument was that 5X5 MHz of spectrum was all we needed for Public Safety. He cited the 3GPP standards body test for LTE capacity, which was to calculate the number of users that could be served within 19 cell sites (57 cell sectors) with a common amount of interference. On its face this paper seemed to prove concisely that Public Safety would have more than enough spectrum. My rebuttal was that you cannot measure capacity for Public Safety as you would for a commercial system. Instead, you need to measure capacity on a per-cell-sector basis because most Public Safety incidents take place within a single cell sector or only a few sectors, therefore it is important to know how much data and video can be transmitted in both directions within a single cell sector where there are multiple Public Safety responders. The report can be found Here .

The tests took place at three different locations (near the center of the cell site, at the mid-point of coverage, and at the cell edge) and Panasonic graciously provided us with a dozen Toughbooks for the tests. We used unity gain antennas in a MIMO (2 antenna per device) configuration and had a server located at the Alameda County EOC. One of my folks who is very good at coding wrote a series of tasks that could be executed on the server remotely to send text and video clips down to the units and to send multiple videos and data streams back up to the server. The results were captured for review after the tests were complete. We also were fortunate that Anritsu provided us with test engineers and its LTE test sets to view the spectrum in real time. The results we obtained after we ran each set of tests multiple times proved how much data and video would be sent and received in a single cell sector. Please remember that these tests were done in 2011 and that LTE has developed well beyond the capacity restraints we found in those tests.

We conferred with the Public Safety community and defined three types of incidents and the number of Public Safety vehicles and personnel that would be assigned to each incident. We had a bank robbery with a potential hostage situation, a multi-story building fire, and a multi-vehicle accident with multiple injuries and extensive damage to the vehicles. The results are shown below as well as our scaling of the capacity tests up to 10 MHz X 10 MHz to show the difference. I am happy to say that the results were widely distributed to the FCC, to Congressional staffers, and to the news media, and we have been told that real-world testing did make a difference in the outcome in Congress.

Those working toward obtaining the full 20 MHz of spectrum were successful and FirstNet was born in early 2012. There was still a concern, at least on my part, whether even 20 MHz of spectrum would be enough when an incident required many Public Safety responders and was only covered by one or two cell sectors. Now that the RFP award winner AT&T has stated it will provide access to all of its LTE network holdings, having enough capacity is most likely no longer an issue.

I say most likely because there could be instances where demand for spectrum access between Public Safety and AT&T’s commercial customers might still put a real strain on the network but unlike with Land Mobile Radio systems where capacity capability is measured across the entire network, with LTE each cell sector and each cell has its own capacity. If one cell is blocked and there is a neighboring cell that also covers into the same area, then the capacity is increased.

Most importantly, just a cell site away from the incident, where the traffic is normalized, the network will continue to operate and provide all of that cell site’s capacity to those in that cell. Further, today’s LTE network technology enables cell site coverage to be trimmed down and also expanded as needed to handle peak loading. A lot of this is done automatically but it is also watched closely by those in the network operations center. Further, as AT&T upgrades its commercial network FirstNet will receive the same level of upgrades including small cell deployment, which will also result in even more network capacity and faster speeds.

I believe what AT&T has done will become a big deal for Public Safety, but I have to also wonder how much of the total available capacity in a given area AT&T will let Public Safety use at the expense of its commercial customers. AT&T, as with the other network operators, is very good at managing network capacity across cell sectors and sites. FirstNet and its new ability to make use of not only band 14 but all of AT&T’s LTE assets will mean programs and people who allocate capacity on a real-time basis will have to add a new variable to their formulas and criteria. It is also incumbent on FirstNet, AT&T, and the Public Safety community to train those in the field so they understand they will have better access to more network capacity but even that has a cap to it.

The biggest issue I believe will be how to make the best use of this new-found capacity without harming AT&T’s existing customer base. I am sure those who study the network traffic models have taken all of this into account, but there will also be a learning curve and more adjustments as more Public Safety users come onboard and make more use of the network. The end result should be that FirstNet has scored a real advantage for the Public Safety community with AT&T’s pledge to provide more capacity as needed. Now we all have to be careful to use it wisely. Andrew M. Seybold

FirstNet Shares Best Practices With Global PeersFirst Responder Network Authority via Google Alerts Apr 20 09:20 At least 17 countries are considering some form of a nationwide LTE broadband network dedicated to public safety. What these nations have in …

FirstNet is now underwayCritical Comms via Google Alerts Apr 19 17:10 The United States’ public safety mobile broadband network, FirstNet, is now officially underway, with AT&T selected as prime contractor.

Communications experts gather at IWCE 2017American City & County via Google Alerts Apr 19 14:10 McEwen is currently the Chairman of the FirstNet’s Public Safety Advisory Committee and has had a remarkable 60+ year career in public safety …

Emergency workers optimistic about FirstNet technologyWBAY via Google Alerts Apr 18 19:10 … Cullen Peltier, director of Brown County Public Safety Communications. Put simply, the system allows public safety to send and receive data, like …

Underdogs Prevail at FCC Incentive AuctionPolitic365 via Google Alerts Apr 18 17:55 This was the largest mobile broadband auction of spectrum below 1GHz in FCC history. Of the 50 winning bidders, 20 represented rural interests and …

FirstNet Weekly Update to the Public Safety Advisory CommitteeNational Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts Apr 18 17:10 FirstNet Weekly Update to the Public Safety Advisory Committee (PSAC) …

FCC Announces Results of Wireless Spectrum Incentive AuctionTelecommunications Magazine Apr 17 17:00 175 TV stations, 50 wireless bidders free up 70MHz for mobile broadband On April 13, the Federal Communications Commission announced the closing of the broadcast incentive auction, which created a first-of-its kind market for repurposing valuable broadcast airwaves for nationwide wireless mobile use. At $19.8 billion in gross revenue for 70MHz of spectrum, the incentive auction is among the highest grossing auctions ever conducted by the FCC. The Commission now commences a 39-month transition pe

FCC Proposes Levying Huge Fine on New York Police Radio JammerARRL via Google Alerts Apr 17 15:10 Commission action in this context is therefore essential to safeguard authorized operations on spectrum licensed for public safety uses, and, …

FCC’s Broadcast Incentive Auction Frees 70 MHz for Mobile BroadbandMicrowave Journal via Google Alerts Apr 14 22:05 On April 13, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) announced completion of the broadcast incentive auction, which raised $19.8 billion in …

Roku Hires DC Lobbyists For First Time To Fight For Net NeutralityTechdirt Corporate Intelligence Apr 20 08:04 With broadband privacy rules dead , ISP lobbyists and their loyal lawmakers have begun quickly shifting their attention to killing FCC oversight of broadband providers and net neutrality. We’ve pointed out how folks concerned about this shouldn’t expect a lot of help from the likes of Facebook, Netflix and Google this go round. We’ve also noted how folks need to begin waking up to the false arguments being used to sell the pitch (namely that…

Tom Struble: The broadband privacy CRA: Much ado aboutsomethingTopeka Capital Journal via Google Alerts Apr 20 01:55 Recently, Congress and President Trump repealed an FCC order from October 2016 that included new privacy and data security rules for Internet …

Trump’s White House is about to make your internet way more expensiveMic via Google Alerts Apr 19 22:55 Broadband providers are kept in check by the government, specifically the Federal Communications Commission. But under the Trump administration, …

Net Neutrality Lobby Attempts to Pit Trump Against FCCInsideSources via Google Alerts Apr 19 21:40 Critics, including PK, describe the market, which provides high-capacity service to businesses, hospitals, libraries, schools, public safety offices, ATM …

FTC May Inherit FCC’s Abandoned Broadband Privacy MissionBloomberg BNA via Google Alerts Apr 19 12:55 A Senate Democrat is fighting back against the GOP’s recent decision to kill off …

Bipartisan Lawmakers Question FCC Plan to Deregulate Business BroadbandInsideSources via Google Alerts Apr 18 23:55 Republicans and Democrats across Capitol Hill are taking issue with the …

National Telecommunications And Information Administration Authorizationwenojipe.ru via Google Alerts Apr 18 14:10 customers privacy . hearing before the Committee on Commerce, …

This Week in Comcast: With FCC auction over, acquisition rumors startxmlpush Apr 18 13:15 The FCC auction is over, the bids are in, down payments are due and now, the speculation heats up. Last week’s closure of the FCC spectrum auction ” designed to transfer broadcasting rights from public TV stations that underutilized them to wireless and broadband carriers ” brought news that Comcast spent about $1.2 billion net for airwaves within its current footprint. Analysts have poured over these results, speculating over what Comcast’s buy-in, which fell far below…

Broadband Network & Device Securitysaxuvado.ru via Google Alerts Apr 18 09:10 You can ….. Is the Verizon. Wireless Mobile Broadband network secure? How can mobile broadband modem security be ensured? Public Safety and.

This Week in Comcast: With FCC auction over, acquisition rumors startxmlpush Apr 18 08:00 The FCC auction is over, the bids are in, down payments are due and now, the speculation heats up. Last week’s closure of the FCC spectrum auction ” designed to transfer broadcasting rights from public TV stations that underutilized them to wireless and broadband carriers ” brought news that Comcast spent about $1.2 billion net for airwaves within its current footprint. Analysts have poured over these results, speculating over what Comcast’s buy-in, which fell far below…

Flake, Sensenbrenner Experience Early Pushback to Broadband Privacy RepealMorning Consult via Google Alerts Apr 17 17:55 Flake introduced the resolution that used the Congressional Review Act to repeal the FCC’s privacy rules, which would have required internet service …

ISPs Gave 8X More Cash to Politicians That Axed FCC Privacy RuleDSL Reports via Google Alerts Apr 17 08:40 They fail to tell you that the FTC doesn’t have authority over broadband providers, can’t make new rules, and AT&T’s lawyers have already found a …

FCC task force continues focus on broadband-enabled healthcareHealth Data Management Apr 17 08:04 Connect2Health helps FCC find areas with limited broadband, high health needs, says Mignon Clyburn.

Don’t Get Too Excited About the FCC’s New Net RulesWall Street Journal Apr 17 08:00 New net neutrality rules will lessen the long-term risks for broadband providers, but they aren’t going to mean big changes.

Broadband, mobile internet services suspended in Kashmir ValleyHindustan Times via Google Alerts Apr 17 08:00 The Jammu and Kashmir police has directed telecom companies to shut their 3G and 4G services in the Kashmir Valley as the state authorities feel …

NTIA’s IoT patching meeting to focus on outcomes, timelineInside Cybersecurity via Google Alerts Apr 17 07:05 The National Telecommunications and Information Administration’s upcoming meeting of its Internet of Things patching multistakeholder initiative will …

Bid request for state’s broadband network draws interestWorcester Telegram via Google Alerts Apr 17 03:10 … running MassBroadband123, the imperiled state-owned network that brings high-speed internet to scores of public safety and government buildings …

Power Line Communications: Theory And Applications For Narrowband And Broadband …zagicugo.ru via Google Alerts Apr 16 08:25 Power Line Communications: Theory And Applications For Narrowband And Broadband Communications Over Power Lines | zagicugo.ru.

President Trump officially signs resolution to overturn FCC Internet privacy rulesNormangee Star via Google Alerts Apr 15 07:40 President Trump officially repealed broadband Internet privacy rules that …

Broadband Access: Republicans Defend Amendments To Internet Privacy Rules, FCC Pushes …International Business Times via Google Alerts Apr 14 17:55 As Republican lawmakers continue to defend their decision to vote to roll back a set of broadband privacy rules that would have required internet …

FCC’s Broadcast Incentive Auction Frees 70 MHz for Mobile BroadbandEESage.com via Google Alerts Apr 14 17:05 FCC’s Broadcast Incentive Auction Frees 70 MHz for Mobile Broadband | 2017-04-14 | Microwave Journal · microwavejournal.com about 3 hours ago.

One broadband choice counts as “competition” in new FCC proposalArsTechnica: Infinite Loop Apr 14 15:08 Price caps would be eliminated when there’s one more ISP within half a mile.

FCC’s deregulation of business data lines could mean a price hikePC World Apr 14 15:01 If you operate a small or medium-size U.S. business, you can expect to pay more for broadband services in the near future because the U.S. Federal Communications Commission plans to deregulate providers of business data lines, critics of the proposal say. Users of ATMs, shoppers in stores that use credit card scanners, and mobile phone customers could also see prices go up after the FCC deregulates the so-called business data services (BDS) market. Schools and hospitals also depend on BDS for th