FirstNet’s Pre-Proposal Conference Thursday, March 10, 2106: FirstNet sponsored a Pre-Proposal Conference in Reston, VA to discuss the RFP, clarify some of its points, and further respond to questions at the end of the session. The event was well attended both in person and via the webcast, and was upbeat in nature. I have to admit that I learned a few things from the webcast that I was not 100% aware of from reading the RFP and discussing it with others. I was aware that FirstNet has $6.5 billion available for the vendor to help defray the cost of the network, but that $6.5 billion can turn into a lot less because there will be holdbacks for each state that opts out. Funds that are held back will make up grants for the opt-out states to build out the RAN portion of the network in those states.
I was also aware that a payment schedule had been set up for the vendor to pay FirstNet $5.6 billion over the course of the 25-year contract, but I did not know until the webcast that the $5.6 billion is the minimum requirement for funding but FirstNet expects the vendor community to offer more than the minimum amount over the term of the contract. FirstNet stated that the funds collected over and above its operating costs incurred each year would be used first to reinvest in the network, which will include but not be limited to funding network upgrades with the successful bidder. Beyond that, some of the monies would be set aside to build up a fund to be used to pay for the next round of RFPs when the 25-year contract is up.
The FirstNet CEO also talked about the true value of the spectrum that would be available to the RFP winner starting the day of contract signing, which would be much sooner than access to any of the 600-MHz spectrum that will be auctioned this year. However, there is still no clear way to determine exactly how much of the 20 MHz of spectrum will be available on a secondary basis to the RFP winner since the number of first responders who will be using the network is unknown and the number of Public Safety applications is unknown. Then of course there is an issue with how much spectrum might be available in Times Square on a Friday or Saturday night. If secondary users need to be moved off due to a major incident, where will they go? This last point speaks to the fact that serious bidders will have to have other spectrum already in use so secondary users can be reassigned to the vendor’s existing spectrum. If a successful vendor does not have any spectrum already serving customers and does not have an agreement with at least one other provider to share existing spectrum assets, secondary users could be booted off the network altogether.
We are told this is an unlikely scenario but I know it is one that weighed heavily on several companies that have decided to walk away from the RFP. My impression is that FirstNet’s idea of what this spectrum is worth may not be the same as potential bidders believe it is, in which case a financial model may be difficult to assess. The number of companies that submitted questions (26) and the number of people who attended this meeting both in person and via the web indicates there is still a strong interest from the vendor community, and I hope it is maintained. Another thing I learned during this event is that since the RFP process is being governed by the FAR (Federal Acquisition Regulation), my assumption that qualified bidders would have an opportunity to sit down at the bargaining table with FirstNet prior to the award may not be correct.
What we were told during the webcast was that under the FAR section that covers this, such meetings may or may not occur depending on what FirstNet decides at some future point in time. So if a vendor is inclined to provide a responsive bid but holds back some additional incentives intended to be placed on the table during discussions, it may not have an opportunity to sweeten its bid. Thus everything a vendor is willing to provide will have to be detailed in one of the three volumes of the RFP response.
During the Question and Answer Period there were several questions about how smaller companies, including rural carriers, can work with prime bidders. The answer given was that they can be added to the list of small companies that want to partner, and according to the FirstNet President, FirstNet expects some of the partnerships to be set up and agreed upon prior to the final RFP response. However, it is also logical to assume that some additional partnerships may be agreed upon after the RFP responses are in. Here again, because of the FAR rule cited above, it is not clear whether vendors will have that opportunity. Another question was about a prime vendor reaching out to some or all of the 900 rural carriers or being able to work with a rural carrier organization such as the Competitive Carriers Association (CCA) instead. The answer to that was basically that FirstNet would not comment one way or another, choose your own approach and include it in your RFP response.
All in all it appeared to be a good day for FirstNet and it does appear as though there are still a number of prime vendors interested in the RFP as it stands after some tweaks were made as a result of some questions asked prior to the deadline on February 12. We were also informed that that deadline was not really a deadline and FirstNet will entertain and perhaps answer more questions until the day the RFP responses are due, which I think makes sense, especially since some of the questions won’t be uncovered until the responses are being shaped.
As usual, there were also a few things that got me going during this event. The first was the reiteration that there is a very tight schedule to award the RFP but no one has ever explained who is setting the dates or the reasoning behind them. I agree this project needs to get off the ground, but FirstNet makes it sound like if they miss the award deadline there will be hell to pay. I don’t buy that, especially when so much is at stake. The other two things that set me off were two comments made by the Contracting Officer toward the end of the Question and Answer Period. The first was in response to a question about the status of FirstNet and whether it is a private organization or Federal. The question was barely finished when the answer came out loud and clear: FEDERAL! This means any semblance of FirstNet being an “Independent Authority” did not warrant an explanation. Honestly, my first thought was that this answer might be the final straw to a prime contractor sitting on the fence. The last comment I will make here is that in her final analysis of the RFP, the Contracting Officer referred to “Her Project” and that the RFP was, after all about an acquisition. And here I had thought it was about a private-public partnership. To everyone’s credit, the most important point came through loud and clear: FirstNet’s stakeholders are the Public Safety community, first and foremost. Which is exactly as it should be. Andrew M. Seybold
FCC Unveils Internet Privacy Proposal – Newsmax via Google Alerts Mar 11 10:02 The FCC has new authority to set privacy rules after it reclassified broadband providers last year as part of new net neutrality regulations. A federal …
FirstNet addresses network performance, rural partnerships and post-RFP negotiations in latest Q&A – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Mar 10 04:50 An entire section of FirstNet’s request for proposal (RFP) that addresses the manufacturing location of equipment for the system was changedan …
FCC Proposes Low-Income Broadband Subsidy Plan – NewsFactor Mar 9 21:00 Broadband Internet service is inching closer to being considered an essential commodity in the United States. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on Tuesday announced proposed revisions to its low-income assistance program that would help more than 64 million Americans to connect online, via $9.25 in monthly assistance per participant. The subsidy is part of the FCCâEU’s Lifeline plan, which was established in the 1980s to help low-income Americans gain access to vital means of…
FirstNet Seeks Comment on Draft PEIs – National Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts Mar 9 06:01 The First Responder Network Authority (FirstNet) seeks comment on a draft programmatic environmental impact statement (PEIS) for the following …
When Will the NPSBN Be Available in Massachusetts? – Mass.Gov Blog via Google Alerts Mar 9 05:20 One of the most frequent questions our office gets is When is the National Public Safety Broadband Network going to be available for first responders …
APCO Seeks Project 43 Volunteers – National Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts Mar 9 00:40 The Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials-International today asked for volunteers to serve on working groups that have been …
FirstNet releases answers to third set of RFP questions – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Mar 8 17:15 … responses do offer insights about how future expansions to the proposed nationwide public-safety broadband network (NPSBN) will be executed.
FCC Chief Wants Broadband Providers To Obtain Consent For Ad Targeting – MediaPost Communications via Google Alerts Mar 11 11:10 For instance, if Verizon wanted to market its wireless service to a customer who already subscribed to Verizon FiOS, Verizon would only need that …
ICC BASIS welcomes IANA stewardship transition plan and related improvements to ICANN … – International Chamber of Commerce via Google Alerts Mar 11 09:55 … has been submitted to the US National Telecommunication and Information Administration (NTIA)and is the result of an inclusive, global discussion …
FCC Proposes Broadband Privacy Rules – Advertising Age Mar 11 05:00 Federal Communications Commission Chairman Tom Wheeler today proposed privacy regulations for broadband ISP services that commissioners will consider in the coming weeks. If passed, the move will be seen as a milestone in digital privacy regulations, as the FCC helps carry a torch long held by the Federal Trade Commission. The FCC’s adoption of net neutrality rules for broadband last year opened a new privacy arena for the agency, which is making good on its promise to move forward on privacy protection rules. “You will see us within the next several months addressing the question of privacy practices of those…
The Dragonslayer: An Interview With FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler – Re/code via Google Alerts Mar 11 02:20 The host of Last Week Tonight had set his sights on the then-raging net neutrality debate, acerbically calling out broadband providers like Comcast …
FCC wants ISPs to get customer permission before sharing personal data – Network World Fusion Mar 10 17:00 Broadband providers would often be required to get customer permission to use and share personal data they collect under regulations proposed by the U.S. Federal Communications Commission. Broadband providers have an unrivaled ability to track customers and collect personal data, and there currently are no specific rules covering broadband providers and customer privacy, FCC officials said Thursday. The goal of the rules is to give broadband customers notice, choice and control over their personal data, FCC officials said during a press briefing. “Your ISP handles all of your network traffic,” FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler wrote in the Huffington Post . “That…
Understanding the FCC’s Move to Protect Broadband Users’ Privacy – Re/code via Google Alerts Mar 10 16:11 Every broadband consumer should have the right to choose how their …
Internet Society Applauds Community-Developed Plan to Transition Oversight of Key Internet Resources – Business Wire Mar 10 15:18 MARRAKECH, Morocco–(BUSINESS WIRE)–The Internet Society (ISOC) Board of Trustees today passed a resolution to strongly support the plan developed by the global Internet community presented to the U.S. National Telecommunications and Information Administration to transition oversight of key Internet resources. The ISOC Board further urged the community to continue its efforts to implement the plan, and recognized that ICANN must continue to make the reforms called for by the community to conti
FCC Proposes Subsidy to Close Broadband Gap – E-Commerce Times Mar 10 15:00 FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler on Tuesday announced a $2.25 billion plan to expand the federal Lifeline subsidy program to help low-income consumers afford broadband Internet service. Lifeline, which currently allows low-income consumers to buy mobile phone service at a discount, would let them buy standalone broadband starting Dec. 1 for $9.25 per month or apply the discount to bundled services.
AT&T snags 700 MHz and AWS spectrum licenses from cable firm BendBroadband for LTE – CompanyOwl.com via Google Alerts Mar 10 09:15 -Fi/MVNO’ products AT&T Mobility , AWS , BendBroadband , Cable One , FCC , Leap Wireless , LTE , wireless spectrum The carrier didn’t disclose the …
FCC’s Mignon Clyburn Names J. David Grossman Chief Of Staff, Daudeline Meme Wireless … – All Access Music Group via Google Alerts Mar 10 07:50 CLYBURN has also tapped FCC Enforcement Bureau Chief of Staff DAUDELINE MEME as Legal Advisor for wireless, international and public safety …
NTIA Offers FCC the Administration’s Recommendations on Lifeline – Benton Foundation via Google Alerts Mar 10 07:15 The National Telecommunications and Information Administration offers comments on behalf of the Administration in support of updating the Lifeline …
NTIA’s BroadbandUSA Announces a Community Connectivity Initiative Workshop, one of the … – Lexology via Google Alerts Mar 10 01:45 … Telecommunications & Information (NTIA) are quite busy implementing the recommendations from the Council’s Report (Report), released last year.
FCC Grants Virginia Waiver – National Public Safety Telecommunications Council – npstc via Google Alerts Mar 10 00:40 The Policy and Licensing Division of the FCC’s Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau today conditionally granted a waiver request filed by the …
FCC Commish Brings In New Chief Of Staff, Legal Adviser – Law360 via Google Alerts Mar 9 20:15 … media policy adviser, and Daudeline Meme will serve as legal adviser for wireless, international and public safety issues, Clyburn said Tuesday.
Obama recommends extending phone subsidy to broadband – U.S. News & World Report via Google Alerts Mar 9 18:00 Now, with more people using the Internet to communicate, the Obama administration says it’s supporting a Federal Communications Commission …
FCC Proposes Low-Income Broadband Subsidy Plan – NewsFactor Network via Google Alerts Mar 9 17:22 Of the low-income consumers who have subscribed to mobile broadband, …
Governments Agree To ICANN Accountability Proposals, Giving Green Light For IANA Transition – Intellectual Property Watch via Google Alerts Mar 9 14:20 … core databases to ICANN from the United States Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA).
Public Safety LTE & Mobile Broadband Market Analysis, Development, Growth and Demand … – EmailWire.Com via Google Alerts Mar 9 13:21 The wide acceptance of commercial long term evolution (LTE) networks is driving the public-safety solution on their mobile broadband. Traditionally …
Verizon Settlement May Signal FCC Broadband Privacy Stance – Bloomberg BNA via Google Alerts Mar 9 09:16 Verizon failed to notify consumers of its use of supercookies to track customers and build unique consumer profiles that it shared with third parties, the …
Public safety broadband a critical enabler : Vic government – Georgetown vs. Villanova live stream: Watch college basketball online via Google Alerts Mar 9 08:40 Law-enforcement and emergency services need their own mobile broadband spectrum, because commercial networks don t have enough remote …
Thousands Ask Congress To Annul Net Neutrality Rules – WebTechReview via Google Alerts Mar 9 04:30 More like this Both abandon accomplish last-minute advance on net neutrality Broadband backers advance GOP-led Congress to annul FCC on net …