Some of the State of New Hampshire’s elected officials and their staffs have been conned, hoodwinked, led down Primrose Lane, or whatever you want to call it. I am referring to the State’s release of RFP DOS# 2016-10, which was released by the Department of Safety, Office of Interoperability, and New Hampshire Interoperability Executive Committee. This RFP starts out as though it was written by FirstNet or the NTIA for the benefit of the Public Safety community. However, later in the Introduction we begin seeing that a vendor has convinced the State to issue this RFP now, ahead of the FirstNet RFP. At an open meeting of New Hampshire’s Statewide Interoperability Executive Committee (SEIC) at which, I am told, this issue was to be discussed, it was simply announced that the RFP had been published.
Several people who were there said those from within the Public Safety community were first stunned, then embarrassed when they learned an RFP had already been released. It is clear from reading the RFP that is was not written by anyone in the State of New Hampshire but by some person or group intent on pushing the State into actions I believe go against the law creating FirstNet. This could well jeopardize the Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network (NPSBN), at least in New Hampshire, denying both the New Hampshire Public Safety community and the citizens it serves this much needed new type of wireless communications system.
While I am not privy to promises made to anyone within the State, it is easy to understand from previous ploys that some vendor(s) believe New Hampshire, and probably other states, do not have to wait for FirstNet. Instead, they can simply purchase a system and install it using spectrum for which they have no lease or a license, start collecting secondary user fees, and funnel them into other State projects. Common sense and due diligence should have convinced decision-makers that this was too good to be true. Don’t misunderstand me, if a state were to issue a Request for Information (RFI) that did not commit to purchasing a system but was part of its opt-in or opt-out due diligence, that would be one thing.
However, this RFP states in section 1.1 Contract Award: “THE STATE PLANS TO EXECUTE A PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP CONTRACT AS A RESULT OF THIS RFP. The award shall be based upon criteria, standards, and weighting identified in this RFP. The State also reserves the right, at its discretion, to award a Contract by item, part, or portion of an item, group of items, or total Proposal. THIS PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP WITH A PRIVATE COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY ORGANIZATION, STEEPED IN FIRSTNET AWARENESS, WILL COLLABORATE IN A BUSINESS-LIKE RELATIONSHIP TO BUILD-OUT AND MANAGE THE FIRSTNET SYSTEM AS IT SPECIFICALLY RELATES TO NEW HAMPSHIRE.” [Editor’s Note: highlights added.]
Section 2. Schedule of Events calls for the award to be made by April 15, 2016, and the notice to proceed (to the vendor) by April 30, 2016, before the FirstNet RFP deadline for bidding. In fact, this RFP was issued by the State prior to having access to the final RFP that will be released by FirstNet in early January. The Spectrum for the NPSBN is licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to FirstNet, an independent authority under the NTIA and the U.S. Department of Commerce. Since the license is nationwide, the only way a State can gain access to it is to opt out by filing appropriate documents with the FCC and receiving approval, with the NTIA and receiving approval, and by entering into a lease for the spectrum with FirstNet approved by the NTIA.
Any vendor that would accept the task of building a band 14 Public Safety network anywhere in the United States, its territories, or on tribal land prior to having a spectrum lease in hand is, I believe, breaking the law, plain and simple. The RFP was obviously written by a vendor and it advocates an award well ahead of the FirstNet RFP award, the State receiving the FirstNet State plan, and the deadline for the Governor of the State to make an opt-in/opt-out decision. It is strange to read sections such as 1.4.3 Testing:
“(17) Prior to operational deployment on the PROPOSED SYSTEM, infrastructure equipment SHOULD have passed FirstNet- required Performance Testing of individual interfaces, nodes and overall system as per the specific performance requirements of the PROPOSED SYSTEM.
(18) Nationwide applications on the PROPOSED SYSTEM SHOULD have passed FirstNet-required security testing to proper security levels (e.g., Criminal Justice Information Services [CJIS]) to ensure protection of FirstNet and public safety information.”
To my knowledge there are no published or established performance testing or applications testing requirements that have been made public or that have been approved by the FirstNet Board of Directors. Reading the RFP is informative and somewhat disconcerting since some of the requirements in the State RFP may not be the same as those in the FirstNet RFP. Therefore, the resultant network will not meet FirstNet requirements for network interoperability, cybersecurity, Evolved Packet Core (EPC), the heart of the network, or a dozen or more other network and operational criteria. And this network is to be completed and ready for service by September 30, 2017, well ahead of FirstNet’s likely schedule.
I believe the State got this wrong in several ways: 1) It will not have access to money raised from use of the network. As I understand it, these funds must go back into the network and be administered by FirstNet. 2) A state cannot purchase an LTE network and put it into operation on spectrum for which it has no valid FCC license and no lease from FirstNet for use of band 14. 3) There is no way a state or vendor can be assured that the network it intends to build will really mesh and be 100% compatible with the overall FirstNet LTE network.
I strongly suspect the vendor(s) in question will use this “win” to push other states into the same scenario, creating havoc for the Public Safety community and/or ending up in Federal Court. It is sad that some vendors are putting their greed and the greed of some unsuspecting well-meaning people within states who believe the state will benefit from secondary network income ahead of the goals of FirstNet. At the end of the day, the states that move forward with this type of scenario will find out just how misled they have been, and how wrong the information they have been provided truly is. However, the promise of money in return for leasing spectrum to others is compelling. Unfortunately, the laws as I understand them and the needs of the Public Safety community are not being considered relevant. I hope this State and others wake up to what is and is not possible with FirstNet as a partner and reject the falsehoods being fed to them.
Statement from FirstNet CEO Mike Poth, December 9, 2015, Board of Directors Meeting The way I read the following statement is that FirstNet will not entertain any deviations from the schedule it has put forth for the RFP, state consultation, and opt-in or opt-out process. “One of the keys that we understand…is that states are getting anxious. But we all have to remind ourselves, the statute does set up a process as to how we’re going to go about; and we’re going as fast as it practically makes sense to get a proposal, select a partner, get state plans out, so that the states can make informed decisions as to what’s in the best interest of their ultimate end customers, the Public Safety community. So we’re asking for your patience. Just hang tight; I know everyone’s getting anxious. We’re starting to hear a lot of states, “We’ve got to get going now.” And we feel that urgency, too. As everyone probably knows, the RFP that we’re contemplating is a result of two years of that effort – the inputs from the consultation, from the states, tribal, federal, all the data collection, the public notices that were put out. We put out requests for the information. We got opinions; we got recommendations; we even got, dare I say, criticisms as to what’s the best way to put this offer together so that we can get the best solution to achieve the mission for public safety.” Have a Great Weekend Andy
New Hampshire issues RFP for public-safety LTE system, but official says no opt-out decision has … – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec 17 13:55 … public-safety LTE network to be built throughout the state before FirstNet is expected to begin construction on its nationwide public-safety broadband …
NTIA Proposes Fee Review For Public Safety Broadband – LexisNexis via Google Alerts Dec 15 23:15 The National Telecommunications and Information Administration, tasked with financial oversight of the $7 billion nationwide public safety broadband …
FirstNet should be applauded for keeping its promise, delivering final RFP on time – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec 10 14:20 … executive, but her dedication to public safety and the FirstNet mission has generated tremendous respect throughout the first-responder community.
Mobile industry agrees on technology standards for global LPWA market – New Electronics via Google Alerts Dec 17 12:20 Industry alignment over common standards for Narrow Band IoT (NB-IoT), …
Testing high power UE in LTE Band 14 for public safety – Rohde & Schwarz via Google Alerts Dec 17 05:10 World’s first high-power user equipment (HPUE) testing has been demonstrated by Rohde & Schwarz and Elektrobit at the GSMA Mobile World …
States Express Concern with Relocation of Narrowband 700 MHz Band Operations – National Public Safety Telecommunications Council – NPSTC via Google Alerts Dec 17 03:50 Several states have expressed concern about how smoothly the relocation of their 700 megahertz band narrowband systems will go, including …
FirstNet Board Committees Meet; Permanent CTO Named – National Public Safety Telecommunications Council – NPSTC via Google Alerts Dec 16 22:05 The four committees of the First Responder Network Authority (FirstNet) board met on December 8 in Houston, and during the two-hour public portion …
PSAC report: Priority, preemption issues on FirstNet likely limited to secondary users, not public … – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec 16 17:22 Dynamic settings also can be established to handle scenarios in which public-safety users need more bandwidth than is available within a cell sector, …
NIST wants to know how cybersecurity framework is used – FCW.com via Google Alerts Dec 11 12:55 … October, Clete Johnson, chief counsel for cybersecurity at the Federal Communications Commission’s Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau, …
FirstNet could provide blueprint for enhancing advance threat defense for public safety, expert says – Urgent Communications via Google Alerts Dec 11 11:55 Public-safety data security needs to be handled at the most basic …
GSMA urges APAC to assign 700-MHz for broadband – Telecom Asia via Google Alerts Dec 10 21:30 The GSMA has urged APAC countries to immediately allocate the 700-MHz band to mobile broadband use in areas where it hasn’t yet been, stating …
FirstNet, DHS P25 comms efforts move ahead – FCW.com via Google Alerts Dec 10 17:20 9 when the First Responder Network Authority board of directors approved a request for proposals to create and deploy a nationwide public safety …
FirstNet board approves RFP for release next month – FierceGovernmentIT via Google Alerts Dec 10 15:20 A request for proposal for the nationwide public safety broadband network was finalized yesterday by the First Responder Network Authority, …
Motorola Solutions chosen for UK’s next-generation public safety communications system – Newsroom – Motorola Solutions via Google Alerts Dec 10 12:40 ESN will support a network based on 4G public safety LTE technology with voice and broadband data services, such as the ability to send photos and …
FirstNet Board OKs Program’s Final RFP, Eyes January Bid Solicitation – GovConWire via Google Alerts Dec 10 10:55 LTEGrid The First Responder Network Authority board has approved a final request for proposal for the FirstNet national public-safety broadband …
FirstNet board approves RFP for public safety network – Telecompaper via Google Alerts Dec 10 05:55 The FirstNet RFP is objectives based and incorporates public safety’s needs for a nationwide broadband network. It was developed after FirstNet …
Wireless LED streetlights transform Gloustershire into smart county – Computer Business Review via Google Alerts Dec 17 13:00 Thousands of streetlights in Gloucestershire, UK, will help make the county smarter by using low power ultra narrow band (UNB) wireless technology.
New LightSquared Reaches Agreement on Spectrum Use for L-Band with Garmin; Agreement Sets Parameters for GPS and Broadband Compatibility – Business Wire Dec 17 11:10 RESTON, Va.–(BUSINESS WIRE)–LightSquared and Garmin reached agreement on spectrum use parameters for terrestrial service in the L-Band relating to the company’s FCC-regulated licenses.
Yet another problem with Comcast data caps: Customers have no idea why they’re exceeding their limits – Boy Genius Report Dec 17 08:45 Comcast sure knows how to bring out the love from its customer base. Cut Cable Today recently filed a FOIA request to the Federal Communications Commission and discovered that the commission has received over 13,000 complaints so far related to specifically to Comcast’s implementation of data caps. It seems that, contrary to what Comcast believes, many people don’t see the “fairness” in Comcast’s introduction of metered usage in the home broadband market. MUST READ: A simple idea that will make Comcast’s data cap much more consumer-friendly So what are Comcast customers saying about data caps? One complaint that really struck…
OmniCISA Pits DHS Against FCC and FTC on User Privacy – Just Security via Google Alerts Dec 17 07:10 Earlier this year, the FCC issued an Open Internet Order that classified Internet broadband service as a Title II service for network neutrality reasons.
GSMA Lauds NB-IoT Standard Agreement – Light Reading via Google Alerts Dec 17 05:15 Industry alignment over common standards for Narrow Band IoT (NB-IoT), Extended Coverage GPRS (EC-GPRS) and LTE Machine Type …
Modification/Amendment – Loren Data’s FBO Daily via Google Alerts Dec 16 22:05 D — FirstNet’s Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network (NPSBN) …
Marco Rubio and Other Senators Move To Block Municipal Broadband – Slashdot Dec 16 08:15 New submitter h33t l4x0r writes: Presidential candidate Marco Rubio recently “fired off a letter (PDF) to the Federal Communications Commission asking the agency to allow states to block municipal broadband services.” The municipal services offer cheaper, faster broadband alternatives to the large telecoms. Rubio’s campaign has taken large donations from AT&T, and the article notes that other providers, “fearing competition, have used their influence in state government to make an end-run around local municipalities. Through…
911 & FirstNet – 911.gov via Google Alerts Dec 16 06:05 The second, seeks to create a National Public Safety Broadband Network (NPSBN) for first responder use in the field, and is in the initial planning …
PUBLIC NOTICE Federal Communications Commission 445 12 th St., S.W. Washington, D.C. … – fcc.gov via Google Alerts Dec 15 21:55 … 2016 On December 7, 2015, Schools, Health & Libraries Broadband Coalition, California Telehealth Network, New England Telehealth Consortium, …
Mobile broadband regulation and net neutrality: One network or two? – Brookings Institution via Google Alerts Dec 15 21:05 Unlike prior FCC orders in this area that the DC Circuit had twice rejected on …
Bad Call! BSE Telecom index hits 52-week low; telcos unhappy over combined spectrum cap – Indiainfoline via Google Alerts Dec 11 12:11 It is said that 700 MHz provides the best result for 4G LTE and is being widely in foreign countries. Since it is a lower frequency, it offers better signal …
India had 108.85 million broadband connections during quarter ending June-15; Rural … – MediaNama.com via Google Alerts Dec 11 07:50 India defines narrowband as internet connections with download speeds less than 512 kbps while the connections with download speeds faster than …
Big Guns and Long Tails – Pipeline Magazine via Google Alerts Dec 11 00:15 More practically though, in the wireless 3GPP world, it has come down to a single standard that is hotly debated, referred to as narrowband IoT, …
Fcc free broadband – Google Docs via Google Alerts Dec 10 22:45 Tennessee battles fcc 39 s municipal broadband ruling. Tennessee blasts 39 …
Patent Suits Plaguing Wireless 911 Services, FCC Told – Law360 via Google Alerts Dec 10 17:55 … with O’Brien Gentry & Scott met with officials from the FCC’s Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau on Monday to push the company’s petition …
FCC Boss Mocks Unfair Comcast Broadband Caps At Industry Dinner, Still Hasn’t Done Squat … – Techdirt via Google Alerts Dec 10 17:05 That obviously puts competing services at a disadvantage, so it raised alarm bells among net neutrality advocates. Comcast, however, has argued that …
GSMA: Delay in allocation of 700 MHz band hinders GDP growth and job creation – DZRH News via Google Alerts Dec 10 15:11 The GSM Association (GSMA) stressed the need for Asia-Pacific countries to allocate the 700 MHz band to mobile broadband use immediately, …
700-MHz allocation – The Standard via Google Alerts Dec 10 12:01 Utilizing the 700 MHZ spectrum, which is well suited to providing mobile broadband coverage indoors and over large areas, can potentially increase …
Public Safety and Homeland Security – FCC via Google Alerts Dec 10 03:25 The FCC’s Public Safety & Homeland Security Bureau (PSHSB) advises, makes recommendations to, or acts for the Commission under delegated …
SK Telecom and Nokia Networks sign MoU for narrowband IoT – Capacity Media via Google Alerts Dec 10 02:00 SK Telecom and Nokia Networks have signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) to jointly research and develop narrowband IoT …